Saturday, December 13, 2014

Saturday Sayings: Close the Door



I might regret ever pondering this matter, but I'm beginning to wonder how the public views their teachers.  I've crossed paths with a few parental comments (not from my personal experience) that have heightened my concern.

"The teachers do not have a choice.  Their salaries depend on their students' standardized test scores."

"I feel that more of the teacher's time is spent 'teaching to the test' and you all seem to be evaluated on what kids do on these tests instead of what they actually learn in your class.  I want my child to have teachers that she can look back one day and know that they loved teaching her."

Comments like these sadden me.  I would hope the public believes we make decisions about the children they've place in our care based on what's best for them.  Instead the message I'm hearing is that they view us as handcuffed by testing, legislature, and curriculum.  They believe we are at the mercies of the unseen puppet masters who make all our decisions for us, leaving us without any to very little autonomy when it comes to doing what's best for our students.  

One of my favorite principals once granted me permission to close my door.  "Do you what you do best," she said.  I took her up on that offer.  I don't believe in a literally closed classroom door, but hypothetically I shut much of the world out of my every day teaching practices.  Some would say I'm spoiled that way--the exception and not the norm.  I know there's some truth to that, which makes me want to apologize to those whose experience is contrary.  I'm unsure of how to fix it, but I believe educators should not only be allowed, but encouraged to do what they do best--to use professional judgment to make daily decisions based on what's best for their kids.

I'd like the public to believe that our energies are focused on their children and not on fighting a system that's enforcing its will upon us and thus upon the children as well.  When possible, just close the door.




Pin It!

8 comments:

  1. It feels like your posts have become particularly brave, of late. I feel inspired and encouraged and super proud to be your cousin.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Laur, you have a way of supporting my bravery in those times when I wonder if it's all a bad idea. Thank you.

      Delete
  2. I love this! I'm with you...have a lot of freedom in what I do and how I do it. So thankful! This is a great response to the comments we are all hearing right now.

    Crystal
    Teaching Little Miracles

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Crystal, I'm thankful to hear you have freedom in your room too. It's a wonderful gift.

      Delete
  3. You said it well! I'm so thankful for the teaching autonomy we have here!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I hear of other teachers too that don't have the freedom that you speak about to teach and make wise, professional decisions for their classrooms. I am so sad for them. I am blessed to have that same freedom and cannot imagine having it taken away.
    Lori
    Conversations in Literacy

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lori, I've heard some of the stories too, and I just can't imagine that kind of situation. It wouldn't feel like teaching.

      Delete